PostcardMania Bewertungen 

Great Job!! More than I expected! Thanks!

“Years of marketing experience,” yet now I’m being told the results can vary because of my audience, competition, and market conditions.

Isn’t understanding the audience, competition, and market conditions exactly what I hired a professional marketing company to help with?

Before the campaign, I was told I could expect approximately a 1–4% response rate from the 2,000 postcards, along with the additional social media marketing. After spending approximately $6,000, I received TWO phone calls.

That works out to $3,000 per call.

Then, when the campaign didn’t perform, the explanations became the economy, the ZIP codes, competition, market conditions, etc. If those factors were so important, why weren’t they properly evaluated before recommending that I spend thousands of dollars on the campaign?

For comparison, I have spent approximately $6,000 on Google Ads and generated more than $250,000 in revenue. The difference in ROI isn’t even close.

And when I posted about my experience on their Facebook/social media, my comments/posts were removed or I was blocked. Consumers considering this company deserve to hear both the positive AND negative experiences.

These are the results of my actual experience: approximately $6,000 spent, 2 phone calls, and no return on my investment.

If you’re considering PostcardMania, please do your research, ask detailed questions about expected results, and decide for yourself whether this is where you want to invest your marketing dollars.

Kevin and Josh do a great job. Highly recommend.

I spent approximately $6,000 with PostcardMania and received only TWO phone calls.

From the beginning, the experience was disappointing. The original design was so poor that I essentially had to design the mailer myself. Then, on the final and most important mailing, my tracking phone number was canceled.

Their explanation for the poor results was that it could have been the economy or that I chose the wrong ZIP codes. But that’s exactly why I hired a professional marketing company. When you’re paying thousands of dollars for marketing, you expect them to help determine the right areas to target, create an effective campaign, and make sure something as basic and important as the tracking phone number stays active.

For comparison, I’ve spent roughly $6,000 on Google Ads and generated more than $250,000 in revenue.

Based on my experience, I would not use PostcardMania again and I would not recommend them. $6,000 spent, two phone calls, and zero return. I would save your time and money and invest it somewhere else.

Years of experience but they don’t know my audience market condition and competition. What a joke

It was quick and great. Works like a charm

Direct mail isn't dead, but cold lists practically are. When we first used PostcardMania to target a general list of "swimming pool owners," the cost was astronomical and our response rate was an abysmal 0.0027%.

We shifted our strategy completely. Now, we use PCM solely for web-retargeting. We use targeted digital media to attract high-intent visitors to our site, then immediately deliver a premium physical mailer to those exact addresses.
In an era where people delete promotional emails and texts in seconds, receiving a tangible, high-quality postcard right after searching for a solution creates a powerful touchpoint. No single channel—whether it's SEO, PPC, social media, or direct mail—works in a vacuum. The magic happens in the synergy.

I really appreciated the quick turn on the edits I needed to make to a web to mail postcard. Hannah was amazing to work with and took care of all of my needs. I highly recommend.

These are great people to deal with! Great results!

I’m a Block Watch Captain for my condominium community of 502 households, with approximately 1,500 to 1,800 people. We’ve experienced an increase in criminal and suspicious activity, so I started a Facebook Group and needed to get the word out to my neighbors. After doorbelling 252 units, I decided to try a double-sided color postcard, with a QR code directing people to the Facebook Group, as a way to speed things up. The postcard was large so that it stood out in the mailbox, and it also explained the Block Watch program using smart graphic designs and photos. I found PostcardMania from an article listing the Top 10 Direct Marketing companies. I called them up and spoke with Richard Barnett who explained how everything would work. Next, I worked with Kevin Kinna who was assigned as my Campaign Coordinator. They designed a terrific mail piece using the photos and information I sent them. There were a couple design changes needed, which they executed flawlessly! The entire experience went smoothly! We did 2 mailings as of this review, and it helped to get the word out, gaining us some new members. I would definitely recommend this company for your marketing needs and I would use them again!

Postcard mania is horrible, I spent $900 and received 0 leads, NOTHING. What a waste of time and money. I do not recommend using them. Then at one point I was told I'd get a refund, or partial and then they came back and said no. I did the social media only, no postcards, I already do Boomerange mailers, plus they charge a fortune for postcards. They say they posted almost 50 thousand ads, and NOTHING. DO not waste your time or money on this company. Customer service was great, but that does NOTHING for my wallet or checkbook. DO NOT USE THEM

I'd like to mention the great service provided by Hannah Sweeney. She has been an angle helping this technology limited person--myself. She always answers my questions with solid answers and always in a very timely manner. She leaves a great impression for PCM.

I received 2 leads. They charged me 6000 dollars. They are a scam. Do not waste your money. They constantly harass you to spend more and more money

Fantastic. They grew Sweetwater Softwash drastically!!!

-Andrew

Great team of people. Very helpful and there every step of the way! Would recommend to anyone.

First two mailings had much frustrations. Poor
communication, lack of follow thru , misleading
postage quotes, poor attention to detail on
creating mail piece.
Third mailing was so much better because
of Elyse Fentsenmaucher. She is the GOAT at
Postcardmania.
Josh Alonso was also very helpful in
straightening out postage issue.

The people at Postcard Mania are great to work with, very accommodating, and get results for us in every campaign. It is the best of all worlds. Thank you for everything!

Ruben is extremely helpful and quick to respond.

Robert my sales agent was fantastic and helpful. Walter took over my account and was friendly, helpful, fast with answers and pretty amazing! This company follows up A LOT, they don't let you stall.

Postcard Mania, they've always been great to work with. Super snappy with getting back to me in the emails and just all around have a great experience with them.

Kevin has been a great resource for me! Patient and informative while understanding the intricacies of my particular business situation. Highly recommend!