Comit Capital Bewertungen 297

I had a really great experience with Comit Capital. The process of buying an account was incredibly smooth from start to finish. everything was clear, fast, and hassle-free.

What really stood out to me was what happened after I unfortunately breached my account. Instead of it being a stressful situation, the whole rescue process was surprisingly simple and straightforward. The support and system they have in place made it easy to get back on track without any confusion.

Overall, I’m genuinely impressed with how user-friendly and efficient everything is. Definitely a solid experience.

They said I opened a trade 2 minutes before the news, which was not possible, I had only two trades that day,

To everyone and anyone reading here is my evidence pulled between my emails and commit capital dashboard.

On April 1st I had two positions opened here are the times below.
2026-04-01 12:33:38
2026-04-01 13:23:58

penalty date according to the email :
04/01/2026 13:58:24
Reason they gave
Violation Name: News trading
Position: Position: 13554228Title: ISM Manufacturing PMISymbol: USDImpact: HIGH

These were 16:00 PM news on the 1s of April 2026

So I checked on Forex factory and the trades were roughly 2 hours before the news mentioned.

So I Opened a ticket to ask what rule did i miss. this was the response they gave me before they closed the ticket, no evidence no details.

"Upon investigation your trade was placed at 15:58 which is 2 minutes before the news was released hence your account has been breached "

I went back to check my dashboard if there is any trade that matches this, and there was none.

The dashboard shows on 1st of april 2026 two trades were closed at the following times

I checked the Analysis hub trading journal to see if I can get anymore information

I saw the 1st of April and checked durations for my trades:

First trade was open for: 1 hour, 24 minutes, 44 seconds

GBPNZD. 2026-04-01 12:33:38 2026-04-01 13:58:22

Second trade was open for:
34 minutes, 18 seconds
USDCHF.c 2026-04-01 13:23:58 2026-04-01 13:58:16

Non are within two minutes of the PMI unless there was another PMI on the same day that was high impact and Forex factory missed.

or number two, there is some hidden rule that we break that is not covered in their terms and conditions, privacy policy and FAQ

I am open to being corrected, but based on the data available to me, there is no evidence of a trade being opened 2 minutes before news.

This raises concerns about transparency and how violations are determined.

Comit capital has been excellent in regards to the service. I am very impressed at the fact that the challenges they have are very affordable as well as vast in regards tp instat funding or running phases. There payment methods are easy and webiste is very user friendly with plenty of promos to assit.

10/10 from me

The account types comit capital offers are the best, they have the best rules for each account which can teach or help alot of traders. It also offers promos that can help traders who don't have enough capital to fund their accounts and start trading at a low cost. Honestly COMIT CAPITAL is the best. I give it infinity %. I highly recommend it.

Comit capital is one of the best prop firm I ever come across. It offers affordable accounts, and one thing I love mostly about them is their support, they reply out email fast, they are more petience on their customers, I remember one day I was breached my account unaware n I was angry and thinking that they scammed me. I emailed the support trying to understand what happened to my account, the person was assisting me give me clear clarification with proof of screenshot. That one made me realize that I'm investing my money with a great team. And again for the fact that it has a daily withdrawals that one of the amazing features I ever come across on this prop firm industry.

Comit capital is amazing it has help me grow as a trader. i have no stress about my bills because when I withdraw I receive my money immediately. The rules a straight forward so you can focus on your skill. They also have a rescue option which is perfect because you can restart the challenge wether phase 1 or 2 for a lower rate meaning you don’t have to restart from phase one if you passed you just continue with phase 2 honestly it’s the best. You won’t go wrong if you choose Comit Capital as your prop firm.

Honestly, my experience with Comit Capital has been really good so far. The rules actually make sense and don’t feel like they’re trying to me. The rules are fair and gave a chance to trade properly.

The rescue feature is probably my favourite part. It’s a big plus because trading isn’t always perfect and having that second chance takes off a lot of pressure. It shows they actually understand traders instead of just looking to fail people.

Everything else has been smooth too, the platform works well, communication is clear, and overall it just feels reliable.

Honestly, Comit Capital is really good.

They make everything super easy to understand and the whole process feels smooth and professional. The team is friendly and actually takes time to help you instead of rushing you.

I’ve had a great experience with them so far and I’d definitely recommend them to anyone looking for something reliable and straightforward.

Overall, really solid service.

Wow my take profit just got hit not even a minute instantly recieve my phase 2 credentials instantly when my t/p got hit only reason I’m giving a 3 star I’ll come back once I receive a payout

One star is even too much. I passed both phases of my challenge. Next thing i see a email saying that i breached my account. This is a predatory company and I would not recommend anyone to trade with them.

I passed my phase 1 and on phase 2 they say I failed but I traded 3 minimum trading days now, but I rescued it even though i passed to avoid days inactive, my rescue payment via Ozow is still showing pending since the weekend. From 27 March 2026 and today it Tuesday still not response from them

CommitCapital here are you layed hard rules, I don't trade news I never breached the account but after yesterday when I passed my account and passed the KYC, they saw that that I passed phase 1 &2 and I was waiting for funded stage login details, boom boom they introduce a new rule to me which did not apply in phase 1 by the way, the rules was trades must be held for more than 10 minutes which was not in their phase 2 rules I took a screenshot of phase 2 rules before they can change them. Phase 1 on 25K I had to make 2.5k which I did beautiful I posted my results on this page and phase 2 I had to make 1.5k on top on 25k which I made 1.6k and yet they failed and I received an email from Sibuyisiwe Gwavu telling me I failed and he introduced a new rule. Wow guys wow

Incredible support and fast replies when needed. In a time of uncertainty the support system provides clarity and direction.

I'm trying to reset my password to purchase an account as I was attracted to the discount on the challenge, however sad to say I have been attempting to reset my password from last week and they can't even help me do that, I receive responses like try from a different device, I have used 2 different devices with still very poor and delayed service

First I didn't read the rules but what I experienced is that prop firm is absolutely good fine When you open the trades you can see is fair. But I will come back again...

I got my first payouts in 6hours . Comit capital is the best .

The credentials are easily accessible effective immediately once you purchase the account and the support team get right back to you once you have question or need help

Their service is not bad. But today i had a bad experience as i requested a withdrawal but its almost over 24Hours and i have not received it as of yet. Otherwise...everything else is a green flag.

Using the funded account is great, reason being it helps traders to begin their trading journey with funds and it makes life easier for a beginner trader

Super impressed with how the team assisted me with my funded account could have had better customer service